Who woud you have as your starting QB?

[KG_CrimsonTrooper]

Forget the hype, seriously speaking, your the GM and you have a decision to make, Between Vince Young or Matt Leinart. who do you choose to run your offense in the NFL...

[KG_Kharkov]

Tough call. It depends on how conservative my organization is. Leinhart is the conservative pick but I don't think he'll be as good as Palmer and he lacks arm-strength according to the prognosticators. In fact, I think he might just be a mediocre pro-QB. Just a hunch but I'm wrong a lot -- I thought Ryan Leaf was a better draft pick than Peyton when they got drafted!

I take the risk on Young and gamble that his passing efficiency rating from college translates into the pros and that his athleticism makes up for his current failings as a traditional pocket passer.

[KG_Panzerschreck]

Niether, id take the Kid from Vandy, Im ttaking the same risks as you guys are on the above mentioned QB's and i wont be spending an arm and leg either, plus i think he's gonna be something special someday.

[KG_CrimsonTrooper]

My choice between the two is Matt becuase he's been running a NFL Pro offense for the last 2 plus years and who's adjustment won't be neraly as long as Youngs. He's much more of a pocket passer who can run if he has to .

[KG_Soldier]

The question is, who wants to adjust their offense to effectively use Young's style? Whoever it is, they'll be happy. I hope. I still think Young (like L. Taylor did to defense) will change the way offense plays football. Texas' receivers were at best average. Young with gifted receivers might just be unstoppable.